Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 Evaluation – A Matter Over Thread Sensor that’s Cheaper than the Eve Movement Sensor

Any hyperlinks to on-line shops must be assumed to be associates. The corporate or PR company supplies all or most evaluation samples. They haven’t any management over my content material, and I present my trustworthy opinion.

The Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 is the third product Aqara has launched that has native Matter assist which is achieved by the thread protocol.

It joins the Door and Window Sensor P2 and the Aqara Presence Sensor FP2.

I’m unsure why they launched this after the opposite two, as I really feel it’s one of many extra helpful sensors you possibly can personal, however I’m glad they’ve lastly launched it.

Specification / Options

  • Native Matter Help: With the arrival of the Matter period, customers now not want to fret about totally different ecosystems and technical protocols, and solely want a Matter app, Matter-compatible Thread Border Router and Matter Controller. Because of this connections throughout ecosystems and platforms grow to be less complicated and simpler.
  • Unbiased Mild Sensor: P2 contains a built-in mild sensor to watch space illumination ranges, with a detection vary of 0-1500lux. It may well modify the brightness and temperature of lighting primarily based on totally different mild ranges all through the day.
  • Excessive-Precision and Vast Angle: Discover P2 that includes a Vast Viewing Angle, with a 170° detection angle and as much as 7 m (extendable to 10 m with Aqara House) vary utilizing PIR Tech. Features a 360-degree adjustable stand for exact movement detection in focused areas.
  • Regionally Handy and Power-Environment friendly: Saving vitality is now not a trouble or effort. Let P2 effortlessly and swiftly make changes and automate duties. For instance, it routinely activates lights and exhaust followers within the lavatory upon detecting somebody, and switches them off when nobody is current. No extra worries about inadvertently leaving residence vitality sources on.
  • Native and Distant Alarm: Place the Aqara Movement & Mild Sensor P2 in key places at residence to assist detect and monitor anomalies. Obtain alerts by way of app or speaker, and hyperlink with different sensible merchandise to create a extra complete safety setup.
  • Simple to Set up and Place All over the place: The sensor consists of an adjustable stand for straightforward wall, ceiling, or horizontal set up, permitting exact P2 positioning for particular space monitoring, like over a desktop. The Movement and Mild Sensor P2 is powered by a CR2450 Lithium battery, which makes its battery life one of many longest amongst Matter over Thread sensors.
  • Unique Options of Aqara House: After connecting the P2 to the Hub M3 and integrating it with the Aqara House app (iOS/Android), it should achieve enhanced functionalities. These embody improved automations, customisable detection timeout and sensitivity settings, movement indication, an area alert system, and extra.

Integrating with House Assistant and SkyConnect

Much like all of the Matter-based units I’ve tried to combine with House Assistant, I had some points getting the P2 to attach.

Aqara initially suggested me that it is because it makes use of Bluetooth for the onboarding course of. The actual fact is that it persistently occurs with House Assistant and SkyConnect however not as a lot with the Google Nest WiFi Professional, indicating the issue is the SkyConnect and never any of the Aqara units or different Matter-enabled units.

As soon as I obtained the sensor so as to add to House Assistant, every part labored as anticipated, and the sensor supplied illuminance and occupancy data in addition to battery life diagnostics.

Integrating with SmartThings / Google House

When putting the P2 sensor into pairing mode, I might get pop-ups for SmartThings so as to add the sensor. This took a few makes an attempt, however it was much less problematic than House Assistant.

Lastly, I used to be in a position to pair it up with the Google Nest WiFi Professional with none issues.

Commissioning Mode / Shared Reference to Different Matter Controllers

With each SmartThings and House Assistant, you possibly can share the gadget with one other Matter controller. As a result of it’s already paired with a Thread Border Router, you don’t want to fret about pairing it with one other Thread Border Router.

With House Assistant, the place you share the gadget, it should arrange a brand new QR code so that you can add the sensor to another Matter controller.

I’m not positive how a lot use this will likely be because the intention of Matter/Thread is to cut back the necessity for a number of controllers and unify all of your sensible residence units, however the possibility is there, and I’m positive will probably be helpful, particularly whereas Matter/Thread grow to be extra established.

House Assistant Settings & Efficiency

Aside from the Matter over Thread performance, that is only a fundamental movement sensor with a superb battery life.

For each SmartThings and House Assistant, you need to use movement, illuminance and battery life as triggers for automation.

I’ve discovered that it’s simply as correct and responsive because the older Aqara sensors I’ve.

It will likely be higher with Aqara M3 Hub

One concern that may inevitably plague many Matter over Thread units is the restricted performance when used with third-party hubs. Third-party hubs may match with the default settings, however any adjustments or superior options usually require you to hook up with one of many model’s hubs.

At the moment, Aqara lacks a hub with Thread, however that is anticipated to alter quickly with the launch of the a lot anticipated Hub M3, which was unveiled at CES 2024. This can be a multi-protocol hub that helps Thread, Zigbee, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and infrared.#

Moreover, the M3 additionally boasts 2.4GHz/5GHz dual-band Wi-Fi and Energy over Ethernet (PoE) connection for additional flexibility and stability.

Worth and Various Choices

The Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 is available for purchase now for £34 on Amazon.

The older, non-Zigbee-based P1 sensor is priced at £25, and a ten% off voucher is accessible.

The far more superior Presence Sensor FP2 is £83 with 15% off obtainable. This requires USB for energy and connects to your WiFi.

Eve is the one different respected model I do know of that has a Matter of Thread sensor. The Eve Movement (Matter) Sensor is priced at £45.

There may be the Avatar Matter over Thread PIR Movement Sensor, which is listed at £24, however I can’t discover it obtainable wherever.

The Qingping Movement & Mild Sensor works with Thread, however shouldn’t be Matter. It as an alternative makes use of Apple HomeKit. It’s simply £25, however it has some combined evaluations.

Total

There may be not an incredible deal to jot down about when reviewing the Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2.

It’s a movement sensor with a superb battery life, and it really works with Matter of Thread.

There may be at present just one different product that straight competes with this, the Eve Movement (Matter) Sensor, which prices 80% extra. Moreover, the Aqara has a 170° discipline of view vs 120°. The out-of-box detection vary is decrease at 7m vs as much as 9m on the Eve, however as soon as the Aqara Hub M3 is launched, it is best to be capable to modify this as much as 10m.

Total, should you particularly desire a movement and light-weight sensor that works with Matter over Thread, then the Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 is the best choice available on the market in the intervening time, for my part.

Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 Evaluation

Abstract

When you particularly desire a movement and light-weight sensor that works with Matter over Thread, then the Aqara Movement and Mild Sensor P2 is the best choice available on the market in the intervening time, for my part.

Professionals

  • Works with a number of platforms with out the necessity of a proprietary sensible hub
  • Might be shared with a number of sensible hubs

Cons

  • Excessive value vs older Zigbee P1 sensor
  • Aqara don’t at present have a hub that helps Thread